1996

BRAVEHEART 8.3
Sense and Sensibility 7.7
Apollo 13 7.5
Il Postino 7.5
Babe 7.4

Looks like they got it right, but they didn't. They were wrong. In fact everyone's wrong about Braveheart, it's a piece of crap. One thing is for sure, no way was it the best of the year.

Nominated in other categories:
The Usual Suspects 8.7
Se7en 8.4