2005

MILLION DOLLAR BABY 8.4
Finding Neverland 8.2
Ray 7.9
Sideways 7.9
The Aviator 7.6

Personally I think everyone's got it wrong here and that Sideways is the best of the lot. But, wait a minute, what about the films which weren't nominated for best picture? Million Dollar Baby may get the nod over the other nominees for best film, but it looks like the wrong films were nominated in the first place.

Nominated in other categories:
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind 8.6
Downfall 8.5
Hotel Rwanda 8.5