2001

Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon 8.2
GLADIATOR 8.1
Traffic 7.8
Chocolat 7.3
Erin Brockovich 7.3

I like Gladiator, but it definitely lost to a superior film.

Of course we couldn't possibly have that other film win, they didn't even speak English.

Nominated in other categories:
Requiem for a Dream 8.5
Amores Perros 8.2