1993

UNFORGIVEN 8.1
A Few Good Men 7.5
Scent of a Woman 7.4
Howards End 7.3
The Crying Game 7.2

No arguments here, Unforgiven is certainly the best of the bunch although it really isn't up against much competition. But the best film of the year didn't even get nominated in the first place.

Not nominated:
Reservoir Dogs 8.4