1984

The Right Stuff 7.8
The Dresser 7.6
Tender Mercies 7.4
TERMS OF ENDEARMENT 7.2
The Big Chill 7.0

What on earth possessed these people to vote for this load of sentimental crap?

Nominated in other categories:
Return of the Jedi 8.2
Fanny and Alexander 8.1
The Return of Martin Guerre 7.5
Zelig 7.5
Trading Places 7.3

Not nominated:
A Christmas Story 8.1
Scarface 8.0